Consultancy Circle

Artificial Intelligence, Investing, Commerce and the Future of Work

Human vs. AI Influencers: The Future of Digital Engagement

Virtual influencers are entering a new phase of prominence, rapidly transforming from novelty CGI characters to complex digital personas that rival their human counterparts. Artificial intelligence, generative content platforms, and synthetic media capabilities are converging to give rise to AI-driven influencers—avatars engineered for brand alignment, audience precision, and round-the-clock engagement. As this technology becomes commercially viable in 2025, the digital marketing landscape is poised to reckon with profound shifts in authenticity, effectiveness, and governance. The central question is no longer whether AI influencers will coexist with human ones—it’s how long they will remain distinguishable, and what the implications of their increasing sophistication will be.

Anatomy of an AI Influencer

The architecture of AI influencers has evolved far beyond scripted chatbot interfaces. In 2025, many popular AI personas leverage multimodal large language models, synthetic voice generation, and deep reinforcement learning techniques to dynamically engage with audiences across Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube. These avatars—such as Aitana López, Rae, or FN Meka—are increasingly autonomous, resilient to fatigue, and optimized for a target audience’s emotional resonance. Aitana, for example, is co-managed by Barcelona-based The Clueless agency and has amassed over 340,000 followers since launching in 2022. Her creators recently told the BBC that she is “designed for profitability,” with earnings exceeding €1,000 per advertisement per week as of 2024—a figure on par with a mid-tier human influencer. [Source]

Few costs are associated with maintaining an AI influencer compared to a human one. Unlike flesh-and-blood content creators, virtual avatars don’t require travel budgets, rest periods, or contractual stipulations for health insurance and labor protections. Their brand compliance is also programmable. According to a March 2025 report by HypeAuditor, AI influencers already represent over 3% of the top 1,000 Instagram accounts engaging in paid partnerships, a figure up from less than 0.5% in 2023. [HypeAuditor 2025]

Advantages and Risks: Comparative Dynamics

To assess the future trajectory of virtual influencers, direct comparison with human influencers is critical. The table below outlines key economic and operational contrasts between human and AI influencers as of Q2 2025.

Category Human Influencers AI Influencers
Engagement Authenticity Higher perceived trust; built on lived experience Synthetic but scalable; limits on deep empathy
Production Cost High (travel, cameras, editing, talent fees) Low post-development; mostly platform fees
Content Cadence Bounded by time, health, and availability 24/7 posting via prompt engineering or automation
Regulatory Compliance Governed by labor and advertising regulations Currently under-regulated; difficult attribution
Longevity Subject to burnout, scandals, or career change Perpetually upgradable; ageless and tireless

The table illustrates how AI influencers offer economic efficiencies and scalability unavailable to humans, but fall short on authentic emotional intelligence. This delineation has meaningful consequences for industries like wellness, parenting, and political advocacy, where audience trust is paramount.

The Market Speaks: Brand Adoption in 2025

Top-tier consumer brands are increasingly willing to integrate AI avatars into their influencer rosters. In early 2025, Puma collaborated with Leya, a hyperrealistic Asian AI influencer, to launch its new Tokyo streetwear campaign—a move that garnered over 3.7 million impressions in under 48 hours. Similarly, LVMH is experimenting with synthetic luxury stylists across its cosmetics vertical, citing improved brand consistency across multilingual geographies and faster content lifecycles. [VentureBeat, April 2025]

One significant motivator: audience engagement rates for AI influencers have surged. HypeFactory’s April 2025 benchmark revealed that AI-led posts by synthetic creators achieved engagement rates as high as 6.5%—nearly double the 3.4% industry average for human macro-influencers. Additionally, young users (18–24) appear more receptive to AI avatars, especially those inspired by anime, digital art, or gaming aesthetics, according to a fresh McKinsey Gen Z insights report. [McKinsey, March 2025]

Governance and Disclosure Challenges

Despite robust uptake, the regulatory gray zone surrounding AI influencers remains unresolved. The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has not yet issued AI-specific influencer disclosure guidelines in 2025; however, updated proposals are under review following public concern over deception and accountability. In March 2025, the FTC called for stakeholder input on expanding “digital actor” disclaimers under its Truth in Advertising framework. [FTC Press Release, March 2025]

Without formal frameworks, many AI influencers disclose their synthetic identity unevenly. Some, like Lil Miquela, explicitly brand themselves as digital, while others obfuscate or blur the line. Transparency failures could have reputational and legal repercussions—not unlike the influencer scandals provoked by undisclosed sponsorships in late 2010s and 2020s. DeepMind’s AI Ethics Group emphasized in their February 2025 bulletin that failure to mandate synthetically generated disclosure for commercial personas is likely to “erode neural trust capital.” [DeepMind AI Ethics, February 2025]

Technical Complexity: Scaling Avatars to Autonomy

Multimodal Fusion and Real-Time Context Parsing

Advanced AI influencers such as Lu do Magalu now use transformer-based LLMs with real-time context awareness—a marked evolution from earlier, heavily scripted personas. These models combine visual-semantic embeddings (like those from OpenAI’s CLIP) with dynamic speech alignment tools such as Whisper or ElevenLabs Real-Time Voice API. The result is an avatar capable of scanning trending hashtags, modifying outputs per platform mood, and holding pseudo-interactive “conversations” in livestreamed environments. [OpenAI Blog, March 2025]

This integration of various modalities makes avatars perceptual rather than merely procedural. It unlocks new use cases beyond advertising—such as AI therapists, AI brand storytellers, and even AI politicians.

Prompt Engineering vs. Persistent AI Memory

One technical frontier influencing AI influencer depth in 2025 is memory retention. Most current avatars rely on short-term conversational context; however, firms like Saga AI and PersonalAI are integrating persistent memory modules that allow synthetic personas to evolve through journaled experiences. This empowers avatars to retain campaign history, user insights, and relational dynamics—deepening their audience immersion. [The Gradient, April 2025]

Persistent memory enables continuity of identity, a key axis that influences brand equity. As user expectations move toward long-term digital relationships, AI influencers that “remember” may hold disproportionate sway.

Forecasting the 2025–2027 Horizon

Looking ahead, human and AI influencer strategies will likely bifurcate rather than converge. AI influencers will dominate tasks that demand content uniformity, high posting frequency, and operational cost-efficiency. These include e-commerce flash campaigns, tier-2 brand launches, or multilingual automation needs. Conversely, human influencers will specialize in authenticity-rich verticals such as social justice, mental health advocacy, and live event coverage—sectors where lived experience and perceived values strongly influence follower loyalty.

This coexistence will also manifest in hybrid models. Already, avatars like Qai Qai—Serena Williams’ daughter’s CGI doll—bridge real-world attachments with artificial bodies. NVIDIA’s Omniverse Avatar Cloud Engine, updated in May 2025, now enables influencers to generate personalized 3D characters mirroring their appearance and voiceprint, facilitating “self-cloning” across languages and platforms. [NVIDIA Blog, May 2025]

For brands, hybrid endorsements could offer the best of both worlds: scalable engagement paired with real-life trust anchors. In campaign terms, human influence may become the emotive nucleus, while AI layers operate as amplifiers across time zones and content formats.

Implications for Regulation, Labor, and Creator Economics

The economic relief AI influencers offer marketers may come at a cost to human creators. Mid- and nano-tier influencers (under 250K followers) are particularly vulnerable, as AI avatars can now be configured for niche segment targeting—vegans in Paris, crypto traders in Singapore, or K-pop fans in São Paulo—with pinpoint optimization. This commoditizes digital influence in ways that push down average CPM rates across influencer marketplaces.

Labor unions, particularly in Europe, have begun lobbying for structural protections. A joint position upheld by German and French creator unions in April 2025 demands that AI-generated media be clearly labeled and that human influencers receive residual honors if their likeness is replicated by avatar tools. The European Parliament is preparing amendments to the AI Act that would treat AI influencers used in commercial advertising under the same disclosure and ethical guidelines as human ones. [European Parliament, April 2025]

As this legal clarity crystallizes, new economic models may emerge based on licensing agreements, co-ownership of avatar IP, and platform-level revenue sharing for synthetic-likeness usage. Long-term, creators who embrace avatarization—in secure, interpretable configurations—may see income opportunities rather than threats.

by Alphonse G

This article is based on and inspired by https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/ce3wyplnev1o

References (APA Style):

BBC (2024). ‘I created an AI girlfriend – now she’s making me thousands’. Retrieved from https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/ce3wyplnev1o
DeepMind. (2025, February). Ethical Disclosure for Digital Avatars. Retrieved from https://deepmind.google/disclosure-ai-ethics-2025/
European Parliament. (2025, April). AI Act Amendments Address Synthetic Media Use. Retrieved from https://www.europarl.europa.eu/news/en/press-room/20250415IPR09873/ai-act-amendments-address-synthetic-media-use
Federal Trade Commission. (2025, March). FTC Reviewing Deceptive Marketing By AI Avatars. Retrieved from https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2025/03/ftc-reviewing-deceptive-marketing-ai-avatars
HypeAuditor. (2025). 2025 Virtual Influencer Market Penetration Report. Retrieved from https://hypeauditor.com/blog/virtual-influencers-stats-2025/
HypeFactory. (2025, April). AI vs. Human Influencer Engagement Trends Q1. Retrieved from https://hypefactory.com/blog/ai-influencer-engagement-2025/
McKinsey & Company. (2025, March). Gen Z Loyalty and Digital Identity. Retrieved from https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/consumer-packaged-goods/our-insights/2025-gen-z-digital-loyalty-trends
NVIDIA. (2025, May). Omniverse Avatar Cloud Engine Gets Major Update. Retrieved from https://blogs.nvidia.com/blog/avatar-cloud-engine-updated-2025/
OpenAI. (2025, March). Real-Time Multimodal Models for Creator Engagement. Retrieved from https://openai.com/blog/real-time-multimodal-support-for-creators
The Gradient. (2025, April). Memory and Agency in Persistent AI Models. Retrieved from https://www.thegradient.pub/memory-ai-agency-2025/
VentureBeat. (2025, April). LVMH Experiments With AI in Digital Fashion. Retrieved from https://www.venturebeat.com/ai/lvmh-experiments-ai-digital-fashion/

Note that some references may no longer be available at the time of your reading due to page moves or expirations of source articles.